What is a Good Cap Rate for Multifamily Properties?

If you’ve ever talked to a real estate investor, you’ve probably heard the term cap rate more than once. It’s one of those numbers that sounds technical but tells a simple story;  how much return you can expect from a property compared to what you paid for it.

In the multifamily world, cap rate is often used as a quick way to measure whether an investment is worth it. A higher cap rate usually means more potential income but also more risk. A lower one means safer, steadier returns but often at a higher price tag.

Investors are paying closer attention to cap rates than ever before. Rising interest rates, shifting rent growth, and changes in demand are reshaping what’s considered “good.” According to CBRE’s report, average multifamily cap rates in the U.S. are expected to hover between 5.0% and 6.5%, depending on the market and property type.

Whether you’re new to investing or expanding your portfolio, understanding how to read and evaluate cap rates is key to making smarter decisions. Let’s discuss what a good cap rate looks like, what affects it, and how tools like Rentana help you analyze the numbers with confidence.

‍

Related: Multifamily vs Single Family: Which is a Better Investment

‍

Understanding Cap Rate Basics: Why Does it Matter?

Before you can decide what a good cap rate is, it helps to understand what the term really means and how it’s calculated. A capitalization rate, or cap rate for short, measures how much income a property produces compared to its purchase price or market value. In other words, it shows you the potential return on investment if you bought the property outright, without financing.

‍

The Cap Rate Formula

It’s easier than it sounds:

Cap Rate = (Net Operating Income ÷ Property Value) × 100

Net Operating Income (NOI) is the property’s annual income after subtracting operating expenses like maintenance, property taxes, insurance, and management fees — but not the mortgage.

‍

A Simple Example

Let’s say you buy a small apartment building for $1,000,000, and it generates $80,000 a year in net operating income.

Cap Rate = ($80,000 ÷ $1,000,000) × 100 = 8%

That means your property has an 8% cap rate, or an 8 percent annual return on your investment before financing costs.

Now imagine a similar property in a high-demand downtown area costs $2,000,000 but brings in $100,000 a year in NOI.

Cap Rate = ($100,000 ÷ $2,000,000) × 100 = 5%

In this case, the second property has a lower cap rate because it’s more expensive relative to the income it generates. This usually reflects lower perceived risk. Properties in strong markets with stable tenants often trade at lower cap rates because investors value their reliability.

‍

What Cap Rate Tells You

Cap rate helps you quickly compare investment opportunities. A higher cap rate often points to better income potential but can also mean higher risk, such as older buildings or less stable neighborhoods. A lower cap rate generally signals a safer investment with steadier income but smaller returns.

For example, a 4.5% cap rate might be excellent for a new luxury apartment complex in downtown Austin, while an 8% cap rate might make more sense for an older multifamily property in a smaller city like Cincinnati.

The key is not just knowing the number, but understanding the story behind it, why it’s high, why it’s low, and what it says about the property’s performance and potential.

‍

Related: How To Calculate the Value of a Multifamily Property Easily

‍

What Is a Good Cap Rate for Multifamily?

The definition of a “good” cap rate changes from year to year, depending on market conditions, interest rates, and investor goals. With borrowing costs staying elevated and rent growth starting to level off in some regions, investors are paying closer attention to what their returns look like on paper, and in reality.

According to CBRE’s U.S. Cap Rate Survey, average multifamily going-in cap rates across major U.S. markets sit around 4.75%, while exit cap rates average 4.96%. Core markets such as New York, Boston, and Los Angeles remain the most compressed, often between 4% and 5%, while secondary markets and value-add properties can range higher, typically between 5.5% and 6.5%. In some smaller metros, investors are still finding opportunities above 7%, especially for older or repositioned assets.

These variations reflect the quality, condition, and location of each asset. To understand how this plays out in real investments, let’s take a closer look at the different classes of multifamily properties.

‍

Class A Properties: 4% to 5% Cap Rate

Class A properties are new or recently built apartment communities located in prime neighborhoods. They usually attract higher-income tenants, offer top-tier amenities, and have fewer maintenance costs. Because they’re seen as lower-risk, investors are willing to accept lower cap rates.

Example: A new luxury complex in Miami might sell at a 4.5% cap rate because of its location, amenities, and strong tenant demand. While the return looks smaller, it’s balanced by long-term stability and appreciation potential.

‍

Class B Properties: 5% to 6% Cap Rate

Class B properties are slightly older but still in good condition and located in stable, middle-income areas. These assets often offer a balance between risk and return, making them a favorite among experienced multifamily investors.

Example: A 20-year-old apartment building in Dallas or Denver might offer a 5.8% cap rate. It requires more active management but can produce higher income relative to its cost.

‍

Class C Properties: 6% to 8% Cap Rate

Class C properties are older buildings, often in less competitive areas or markets that require renovations. They come with more management and maintenance challenges but can deliver strong cashflow for investors who are hands-on or value-driven.

Example: A 40-unit building in a smaller market like Memphis or Cleveland might trade at a 7.5% cap rate. The returns are higher, but so are the risks of vacancy or repair costs.

‍

Recommended: 7 Best Asset Management Reporting Software for Multifamily

‍

How to Interpret These Numbers

A low cap rate doesn’t always mean a bad deal, and a high cap rate doesn’t automatically mean a great one. It all depends on your investment strategy.

• If you’re focused on long-term stability, lower cap rates in strong markets can make sense.
  
  
• If you’re chasing higher income, you might look for higher cap rates in growing but less saturated areas.
  
  

The smartest investors are those who combine both perspectives, understand the numbers, and also the story behind them.

‍

Factors That Affect Cap Rates

Cap rates don’t exist in a vacuum. They change from property to property and market to market based on several key factors. Understanding what drives these differences helps investors make smarter decisions about where to buy and how much to pay.

Below are some of the biggest influences on multifamily cap rates.

‍

1. Location

Location is one of the strongest drivers of cap rates. Properties in major metropolitan areas like New York, Los Angeles, or San Francisco tend to have lower cap rates because demand is high, and investors are willing to pay more for stability. On the other hand, smaller or emerging markets such as Charlotte, Boise, or Tulsa often offer higher cap rates because prices are lower and risks are slightly higher.

Example: A multifamily building in Manhattan might trade at a 4% cap rate, while a similar property in Kansas City could sell at a 7% cap rate. Both can be good investments, but they appeal to different types of investors, one values stability, the other higher returns.

‍

2. Property Class and Condition

The age, condition, and quality of a building directly affect its cap rate. Class A properties; those newer, well-maintained, and filled with amenities, tend to have lower cap rates due to their lower risk and higher tenant demand. Older or less updated Class B and C properties often have higher cap rates because they may need more maintenance or renovations.

Example: A 2-year-old luxury complex in Austin might sell at a 4.8% cap rate, while a 25-year-old mid-tier apartment building in the same area could trade closer to 6%. The difference reflects the maintenance costs and perceived risk of each investment.

‍

3. Local Economic Conditions

A region’s job market, population growth, and overall economic health all play major roles in determining cap rates. Areas with strong employment, rising wages, and new development typically have lower cap rates because of steady tenant demand. Regions facing slower growth or economic uncertainty often have higher cap rates to attract investors.

Example: Cities like Phoenix and Raleigh, which continue to see strong job creation, have maintained cap rates around 5% to 5.5%. In contrast, slower-growth regions in the Midwest might see averages closer to 7%.

‍

4. Rent Growth and Occupancy Rates

When rents are rising and occupancy is high, properties tend to trade at lower cap rates. Investors are willing to accept smaller returns in exchange for reliable income and future rent growth. However, when vacancy rates increase or rents start to flatten, cap rates rise to reflect the added risk.

Example: In markets where occupancy remains above 95%, like parts of Florida and Texas, cap rates have held steady at lower levels. But in areas with softening rent demand, such as some West Coast metros, cap rates have widened by 50 to 100 basis points since 2023.

‍

5. Interest Rates and Financing Costs

Interest rates are one of the most direct influences on cap rates. When borrowing costs rise, investors often expect higher returns to offset the increased cost of capital. This typically causes cap rates to increase. When rates fall, cap rates compress as cheaper financing makes lower returns more acceptable.

Example: During the low-interest period of 2021, some Class A properties traded below 4%, with rates still higher, those same assets are averaging between 5% and 6% as buyers adjust to new financing realities.

‍

Understanding these factors helps investors avoid taking numbers at face value. A “good” cap rate always depends on the story behind it, where the property is, what condition it’s in, and how the local economy is performing.

‍

Read Also: How To Do A Rental Market Analysis Like a Pro (With AI Tools)

‍

How Tools Like Rentana Help Investors Evaluate Cap Rates

Knowing what a good cap rate looks like is one thing. Understanding why it’s good and whether it will stay that way, is another. That’s where data-driven tools like Rentana come in.

Rentana gives multifamily investors, property managers, and asset owners the insights they need to evaluate properties with confidence. Instead of relying on general market averages or static spreadsheets, users can see how a property’s performance compares to others in its market, what future rent growth might look like, and how small pricing changes could affect returns.

Here’s how Rentana helps investors take cap rate analysis to the next level:

• Market and Rent Forecasting: Rentana predicts rent trends across neighborhoods and zip codes, helping investors see where income growth is likely to rise or slow. This makes it easier to forecast future NOI and determine how that impacts cap rates.
  
  
• Real-Time Market Comparisons: The platform lets users compare properties side by side, showing which assets are outperforming and which are lagging behind. You can see how your property’s returns stack up against market averages and identify hidden opportunities.
  
  
• Performance Analytics: Rentana’s reporting tools visualize key metrics such as rent growth, occupancy, and renewal performance. Instead of piecing together data from multiple reports, you get a clear picture of your portfolio’s overall health in one place.
  
  
• Revenue Intelligence: Beyond cap rates, Rentana helps you uncover trends that drive real profitability. It combines market data with proprietary insights to show not just how your properties are performing today, but where they’re heading next.
  
  

For investors, understanding cap rates helps predict how that number will change over time. Rentana turns complex data into clear insights, helping investors make smarter, faster, and more profitable decisions.

‍

Don’t Miss: Is Multifamily Considered Commercial?

‍

Conclusion

A good cap rate for multifamily properties is a reflection of market conditions, property quality, and investor strategy. While averages may range between 5% and 6.5%, what truly matters is how that figure fits your goals, location, and risk tolerance.

The smartest investors don’t chase the highest cap rate. They look for properties where strong fundamentals meet long-term potential. Tools like Rentana make that process easier by turning raw data into meaningful insights that reveal not just where the market is, but where it is heading.

Real estate success is about clarity, timing, and informed decisions. With the right data and tools, every investor can move beyond guessing and start investing with confidence.

‍